Question
Thank you for your time and assistance in this matter. I have a near and dear friend who has committed one horrible mistake in her life and it is ruining her life. I am trying to help her by shedding some light on her situation and showing her that there is hope, however I am a bit confused on a few issues and would like to clarify them before using them as a means to help her.
First of all, I know that there is a Hadith that says that if someone were to commit illegal sexual intercourse and were to get the prescribed punishment (i.e. stoning for the married, lashes for the unmarried) that would be expiation for their sin and it would be forgiven. I was confused with Surah Al-Furqan, I believe it begins with Ayah 68, in which it states that for such sin, the punishment is doubled ... I am understanding that to mean that one would receive the earthly punishment for such a crime and then receive punishment in the hereafter...am I correct? If so, then where does that leave the Hadith that states that the earthly punishments would be an expiation for the sin?
Second of all, I cannot read Arabic so I am only able to read the English translations of Qur’an and lately I have been noticing that there is abrogation in the Qur’an, meaning that one verse is cancelled out by another. My question is regarding Surah Al-Nisaa, Ayah 15...it was abrogated by Surah An-Nur verse 2, which ordained the Hadd for the person/persons guilty of illegal sexual intercourse. What about Surah Al-Nisaa, Ayah 16 which says that if two persons guilty of illegal sexual intercourse repent and amend their ways, leave them alone? Is that also of the abrogated verses? Is the repentant Zani/Zania to be left alone?
My third and final question is in regards to a child conceived through Zina. I have recently seen on your website a number of people asking questions in regards to what the child produced of Zina's status is to his father and you stated that the child is not to be traced back to the father and would only be a stepchild if he and the mother were to marry. I have not yet come across anything about that particular topic in my reading of Qur’an or Hadith; however I am not very far in my reading, so I would appreciate it if you could let me know where to find the supporting evidence of that. Also, I would like to know what the status of a child is to the father if the husband and wife conceived the child and the wife committed Zina after she was pregnant. Is that child linked to the father? And at that point, what is the marital status of the couple (if the wife is fully repentant, changed and was unaware that intercourse with a man who was not the father of the child was a sin outside of Zina?
Your help is greatly appreciated and may Allah grant you many Hasanat for helping someone who I fear is greatly despairing.


Search Fatwa 

